The Collective American Memory
Human memories return in nonlinear and sporadic chunks. We revive
facts, events, and impressions, sometimes slowly and other times all at once.
American culture dictates how citizens should collectively respond to memory,
even those only really remembered by few. There are acceptable behaviors that
society requires of people in the face of certain tragic events.
After a great war, the
returning veterans are the only people who can truly remember the battlefield;
the sound of gunfire, the smell of blood, the sight of dying men. American
citizens participate in moments of silence, visit memorials and pray for
soldiers they may never have known. Anything less would be considered disrespectful
to the lives of the lost. The simple knowledge that horrible things took place
is not what inspires people to respond in such a way. Instead it is the feelings
that stories and carefully designed monuments instill. The power of nostalgia,
the wistful desire to return that which is now lost, is the only reason these
people can be moved by memories that they did not experience.
Nostalgia creates the sense of
complete and utter loss. Stories and war memorials create this collective American
nostalgia; a loss can be felt by all. America is united in their sadness not
by a real memory, but by this feeling. Memorials without attached emotion would be
insubstantial to create this effect.
In Postcards from the Trenches, Allyson Booth
explores the purpose of war memorials, "These artifacts moved toward closing
one of the most important gaps separating the experience of soldiers and
citizens."
The gap between veterans and citizens is memory, and the ability
to truly recall what transpired. Memorials and stories instill feelings in their
viewers and listeners, not only respecting the lost but helping to unite the
returned soldiers by making them feel less alienated. Through memorials and emotions
like nostalgia, people can be made to feel and understand.


Great analysis. Memorials can take away some of the pains of the soldiers. However, if the veterans are the only ones that have experienced the atrocities of war, then how could the civilians possibly understand the pain? Even if the civilians have lost someone, it is not likely that their body was blown up with a grenade or shot up to pieces. This hardship of connecting back to civilization is a problem for many veterans, leaving them with society disorders such as PTSD.
ReplyDeleteI love this post. I agree with the idea that memory is nonlinear and comes back to us in pieces. The part about us visiting memorials and praying soldiers that we've never met really made me think. Great job!
ReplyDelete